Constructor: Patrick Blindauer and Andrea Carla Michaels
Relative difficulty: Easy-Medium
THEME: MAC- to MUCK- vowel progressionTheme answers:- 20A: Subject of the book "Revolution in the Valley" (MACINTOSH)
- 28A: Person who works with dipsticks (MECHANIC)
- 37A: People in this may have big ears (MICHY MOUSE CLUB)
- 45A: Sioux shoe (MOCCASIN)
- 56A: Journalist of the Progressive Era (MUCKRAKER)
Word of the Day: KOKO (
58D: Gorilla pioneering in sign language) —
As with other
ape language experiments, the degree to which Koko masters these signs has been controversial, as has been the degree to which such mastery demonstrates language abilities.
• • •
Pretty standard vowel progression puzzle.
MICKEY MOUSE CLUB makes a nice centerpiece, and
MUCKRAKER's kind of a juicy word, but the rest of the theme stuff is just so-so, as is the fill. Too much crosswordese—all through the middle, and in that SE corner, and otherwise sprinkled throughout. Interesting move to float
MECHANIC and
MOCCASIN away from the edges by one square; that likely made filling the whole middle area much easier. Trying to drive 5-letter Downs cleanly through a 15 on either end can be a dicey proposition. Oh, wait ... now that I look at that middle more closely, I see that making those theme answers flush with the edges would've left a central Down answer with the letter pattern M-O-N, which is nearly impossible (MY OWN might work, though that's not great and also not in the cruciverb database). Flipping the positions of those theme answers wouldn't have helped either. So floating them away from the edge, even if the result is
ENOKI (a piece of crosswordese I actually kind of like), makes the grid workable. It's awfully hard to drive a short answer through three theme answers. So the mess in the middle is somewhat understandable if you consider the technical problem of positioning these particular theme answers.
Really, really don't like
KNEE preceding ON ONE. Awkward. Also don't like
ADASH. At all. APINCH would not be legal, to say nothing of ATEASPOON, so ... no. I didn't know there was anything particularly cowboyish about
GRUB, so getting started in the NW took an extra few seconds while I scrambled around until I found
RITA. After that, very little resistance. I was very familiar with all the specialized crosswordese like
ENOKI and
CRU, and I once put
KOKO in a puzzle, so nothing but my inability to spell
MOCCASIN right the first time had any impact on my solving time. Finished just 3 seconds slower than yesterday's puzzle, and faster than any Tuesday I've solved in the past two months.
Signed, Rex Parker, King of CrossWorld
No comments:
Post a Comment